CoD vs some other sims that model Kent?

[Hatch]

Originally Posted by David Hayward

WoP can do all that because it's an arcade game on a tiny map with green puke covering up all the stuff that doesn't look quite so good.

Well those are actually separate issues.
It's kinda like saying Cindy Crawford is ugly beacuse she has a mole and doesn't play rugby.(Choice of Cindy does put my age into perspective LOL)

It's more like...
It looks good but it's covered in green puke and is arcadey.

[pupaxx]

I cleaned the greenpuke....
C'mon some serenity in judging this...
CoD.jpg WoP.jpg

[David Hayward]

Originally Posted by pupaxx

I cleaned the greenpuke....
C'mon some serenity in judging this...
Attachment 5763 Attachment 5764

If you were looking for images where WoP looks better than CoD, you made a very poor choice. That CoD image almost looks like a photo.

[pupaxx]

Originally Posted by David Hayward

If you were looking for images where WoP looks better than CoD, you made a very poor choice. That CoD image almost looks like a photo.

I thought exactly the opposite! LOL

The judgement is extremely subjective. I thought the matter can be confined in photorealistic or pleasant/enjoyable/agreeable. But we can discuss till tomorrow what is Photorealistic for me/you/allofus...
Luckly we'll got only what maddox Games will give us.., no choise! Stop
However I'm gratefull for this game and conforted in his future upgradebility!
Ciao

[Hatch]

Originally Posted by pupaxx

I thought exactly the opposite! LOL

The judgement is extremely subjective. I thought the matter can be confined in photorealistic or pleasant/enjoyable/agreeable. But we can discuss till tomorrow what is Photorealistic for me/you/allofus...
Luckly we'll got only what maddox Games will give us.., no choise! Stop
However I'm gratefull for this game and conforted in his future upgradebility!
Ciao

LOl you beat me to it.
Perception is so subjective by definition.

[David Hayward]

Originally Posted by pupaxx

I thought exactly the opposite! LOL

The judgement is extremely subjective. I thought the matter can be confined in photorealistic or pleasant/enjoyable/agreeable. But we can discuss till tomorrow what is Photorealistic for me/you/allofus...
Luckly we'll got only what maddox Games will give us.., no choise! Stop
However I'm gratefull for this game and conforted in his future upgradebility!
Ciao

I can, and have, posted photographs that closely match what CoD looks like. You can't do the same for WoP unless you find a really crappy photographer or take the photo in REALLY crappy weather.

[pupaxx]

Originally Posted by David Hayward

I can, and have, posted photographs that closely match what CoD looks like. You can't do the same for WoP unless you find a really crappy photographer or take the photo in REALLY crappy weather.

The picts you posted are real for sure but I dislike those! I would not a game perfectly adherent to a tasteless photo! I'll prefere a clearly fictious atmosphere but convincing, immersive. It'a videogame! Well, I accept his nature (computer generated image sequencies). Here is the subjectivity.
During Flying legends in Duxford I usually shot 4000 pict in 2 days. 99% of them are inexpressive for light condition but real. I dont print them. Even real restored warbirds are 'toysh' (hope is the correct word) 4 my taste compared to my cultural background and how I dream up on them. When I was a child I made my fantasies on Clostermann 'Big show' (also Playboy ). These fantasies were more rewarding than touch a real glossy restored warbird.
This game may be not photorealistic, it's ok but it must make me dream!Even with green filters.

[David Hayward]

Originally Posted by pupaxx

I would not a game perfectly adherent to a tasteless photo! I'll prefere a clearly fictious atmosphere but convincing, immersive.

That is contradictory. If the look of the game is clearly fictitious, then the immersion is terrible. The game should look as close to real life as possible. I'm also pretty confident that the CoD devs are never going to change the game to look like you want it to look.

[Letum]

Originally Posted by David Hayward

If you were looking for images where WoP looks better than CoD, you made a very poor choice. That CoD image almost looks like a photo.

You do know that the Tiger moth one is the one from CloD, right?

[David Hayward]

Originally Posted by Letum

You do know that the Tiger moth one is the one from CloD, right?

Really?? I thought the photo with the puke green hue was CoD?