Log in

View Full Version : Since CloD is over


BH_woodstock
12-18-2012, 04:53 PM
Can we please have the ALL the tools now???
since it is official i was wondering if we can have the tools to do with CloD what we can?I remember it was promised in the past and then we were told "no" because of possible future development,but since Clod is a stand alone and "abandoned" can we have what we need to make it "our" project?This community has been dedicated 100% and it would be pretty cool to have these tools available.
I know there are a few out there that would really like this and would do their best to make it nice.

bongodriver
12-18-2012, 04:59 PM
Guys, the tools don't exist, they were never finished, this community stuck a middle finger up at CoD so 1C threw a hissy fit and fired Luthier and MG then flipped us the bird right back, 1C don't give a crap about any of us any more, they have washed their hands of the whole affair.

Falstaff
12-18-2012, 05:23 PM
Bongo....yeah, what a great fan you turned out to be. What a great voice for the game, what a helpful soul, what a moderate, balanced voice. What nice, grateful view of 'your own' developers.

With 'friends' like you, they didn't need enemies.

Says it all.

Goodbye, Bonkers. See you soon.

bongodriver
12-18-2012, 05:26 PM
Bongo....yeah, what a great fan you turned out to be. What a great voice for the game, what a helpful soul, what a moderate, balanced voice. What nice, grateful view of 'your own' developers.

With 'friends' like you, they didn't need enemies.

Says it all.

Goodbye, Bonkers. See you soon.

Ok bye....

Hood
12-18-2012, 06:52 PM
Ok bye....

Hehe Bongo you and Falstaff are like a married couple. Kiss and make up?

CLOD and "whiners" are a bit like the chicken and egg i.e. which came first? I reckon CLOD but it was a turkey. Sadly they couldn't do all the necessary fixes in time to release a sequel in order to get more working capital. Having to make so many fixes to a deeply flawed piece of software is what killed CLOD.

It's a real shame but there you go. The future is now brighter and I the meantime I'll have fun with CLOD as it is now.

Hood

bongodriver
12-18-2012, 07:02 PM
Hehe Bongo you and Falstaff are like a married couple. Kiss and make up?

CLOD and "whiners" are a bit like the chicken and egg i.e. which came first? I reckon CLOD but it was a turkey. Sadly they couldn't do all the necessary fixes in time to release a sequel in order to get more working capital. Having to make so many fixes to a deeply flawed piece of software is what killed CLOD.

It's a real shame but there you go. The future is now brighter and I the meantime I'll have fun with CLOD as it is now.

Hood

Falstaff is always welcome to make an appology to me and I would always consider accepting it..

I think you will find the whiners came before CoD, Tree made quite a stink for many a year before release and built himself a little cult following.....probably consisting of a large proportion of his own aliases.
if flawed software guaranteed failure then I don't think there would be any in existence, CoD was buggy, if I had a dollar for every buggy game I ever bought I'd have several hundred dollars, no the game didn't make money because enough people whined about it and it became undesireable, now we are going to wait a year for something inferior but works out of the box like a console game which I think is a backup plan.

Fjordmonkey
12-18-2012, 07:04 PM
Can we please have the ALL the tools now???
since it is official i was wondering if we can have the tools to do with CloD what we can?I remember it was promised in the past and then we were told "no" because of possible future development,but since Clod is a stand alone and "abandoned" can we have what we need to make it "our" project?This community has been dedicated 100% and it would be pretty cool to have these tools available.
I know there are a few out there that would really like this and would do their best to make it nice.

There isn't any tools to release. Did you miss BlackSix' announcement on that?

BH_woodstock
12-18-2012, 07:56 PM
There isn't any tools to release. Did you miss BlackSix' announcement on that?

looks like i did miss that one.thanks for the replies guys

~S~

He111
12-19-2012, 09:34 AM
Guys, ... this community stuck a middle finger up at CoD so 1C threw a hissy fit ....

When did we do that ?? I suspect poor sales put 1C into extreme financial stress .. thus they did something not smart - dump CLOD. In 2 years time when the world economy is normal again, CLOD will still be a sort after flight sim.

.

bongodriver
12-19-2012, 09:47 AM
When did we do that ??


Where have you been for the last year? poor sales is us not getting the wallets out, how many threads have we seen where people happily claim to have bought every flight sim title without playing it just to support the industry? but when it came to CoD it all changed and I am scratching my head wondering what they did to the flight sim community that made them turn so sour, promised too much? really? even if they fell short on the promises they gave us more than we had ever seen before.

He111
12-19-2012, 10:49 AM
Where have you been for the last year? poor sales is us not getting the wallets out, how many threads have we seen where people happily claim to have bought every flight sim title without playing it just to support the industry? but when it came to CoD it all changed and I am scratching my head wondering what they did to the flight sim community that made them turn so sour, promised too much? really? even if they fell short on the promises they gave us more than we had ever seen before.

WE IL2-buffs did put our hands in our pockets even though most needed PC ugrades they couldn't afford (After GFC) ..so i suspect most IL2 simmers did do their duty even if they complaigned it wouldn't work on a XP running DOS 3.1. I suspect it was the gamers who bought IL2 - 1946 during the good times, abandoned CLOD during the bad. "fair weather simmers". I could be wrong, obviously 1C forcasters got it terribly wrong.

I still think abandoning CLOD now implies 1C thinks PC Flight simming is DEAD! why do they think that? WW2 buffs getting too old ? young people don't understand WW2 ? maybe ? but good advertising can sell anything .. 1C promoters obviously didn't do their job.

.

SlipBall
12-19-2012, 11:05 AM
WE IL2-buffs did put our hands in our pockets even though most needed PC ugrades they couldn't afford (After GFC) ..so i suspect most IL2 simmers did do their duty even if they complaigned it wouldn't work on a XP running DOS 3.1. I suspect it was the gamers who bought IL2 - 1946 during the good times, abandoned CLOD during the bad. "fair weather simmers". I could be wrong, obviously 1C forcasters got it terribly wrong.

I still think abandoning CLOD now implies 1C thinks PC Flight simming is DEAD! why do they think that? WW2 buffs getting too old ? young people don't understand WW2 ? maybe ? but good advertising can sell anything .. 1C promoters obviously didn't do their job.

.

Recession was a big factor for sure, just look at my rig :oops:...Steam I think was a big problem early on. Almost like it was grading your system, what's this guy kidding me CTD, Steam says take that looser

Fjordmonkey
12-19-2012, 12:21 PM
I still think abandoning CLOD now implies 1C thinks PC Flight simming is DEAD! why do they think that? WW2 buffs getting too old ? young people don't understand WW2 ? maybe ? but good advertising can sell anything .. 1C promoters obviously didn't do their job.

.

I'd say that they're probably realizing that the high-end flight-sim market is so incredibly small overall that it's not a market that's hardly worth throwing money at, and that in the case of CLoD that the return wasn't worth the time and money invested into the project. I mean, 8 years or so, and gods know how many millions of $$ into one game? Even with UbiSoft on their back, that's a tad long to develop a product that is aimed at a very narrow band of buyers.

I don't think the abandonment of CLoD implies that 1C feels PC flightsimming is dead. What it does imply is that sooner or later the beancounters and/or investors are going to say stop and then terminate the project when they see that it doesn't look like the investment is going to pay off soon, or in CLoD's case: at all.

After all, it's all business these days. And in business, money talks and bullshit walks. CLoD took a walk, which is sad.

Stublerone
12-19-2012, 04:42 PM
With a good initial start, this wouldn't have happened. There are not millions of dollars of invest here. Otherwise the game wouldn't have ran that bad! Perhaps 2 mio? Do not know, but when you perform like this and the game result is this, they really cannot compete on the marjet, as this game in this long period seem to be done by perhaps 20 people.

Noone ever claim the way you are saying it now. Bongodriver just talks a lot of trash, when day is long. You see many people enthusiastically talking about any aspect of this game and hold the hand of 1c now for nearly 1 decade overall and over 2 hard to understand, problematical years.

You now see it as claim, but you can also see it as suggestions and a discussion.

As this comunity turned out to be well knowledged, the discussion have this negative aspect for sure - no doubt. But the fact, that everyone had an eye on this game, although it was unplayable, should say us all, that all cared about this game.

Give it to oleg maddox, when he returns to the gaming manufacturing and let him set up a kickstarter project and let him present his ambitious visions, perhaps combining other aspects to a new ww2 sim and you will see the same as in star citizen from chris roberts.

Well advertised and speaking to the souls of core gamers and not to casual gamer and console gamers lets him get easily 7mio dollars with just 100.000 backers, which is 70 dollars average. And you backed for something, which you also do not know, how it turns oit to be.

But this is the way to go. Not shift it somewhere else, but setup new ways. As ROF engine will also have problems to accurately simulate the fm and as it has no ground objects routines, the current engine is far away from a standard, which you would need. Hopefully they get it, but I doubt.

And it is not one year! It is more like 2-3 years. So, BOM release in middle 2014 optimistically said in my opinion. :)

Ailantd
12-19-2012, 04:43 PM
where have you been for the last year? Poor sales is us not getting the wallets out, how many threads have we seen where people happily claim to have bought every flight sim title without playing it just to support the industry? But when it came to cod it all changed and i am scratching my head wondering what they did to the flight sim community that made them turn so sour, promised too much? Really? Even if they fell short on the promises they gave us more than we had ever seen before.

+100

Ernst
12-19-2012, 09:45 PM
Just open the source code. The community deserves at least this:grin:...

JG52Krupi
12-19-2012, 10:23 PM
Where have you been for the last year? poor sales is us not getting the wallets out, how many threads have we seen where people happily claim to have bought every flight sim title without playing it just to support the industry? but when it came to CoD it all changed and I am scratching my head wondering what they did to the flight sim community that made them turn so sour, promised too much? really? even if they fell short on the promises they gave us more than we had ever seen before.

Yeah, that's what I don't get...

ATAG_Dutch
12-19-2012, 11:48 PM
Since CloD is over......

In the words of the late and great James Marshall Hendrix,

'As we all know, you can't believe everything you see and hear, can you?'

EXP - Bold as Love album. :D

Sokol1
12-20-2012, 02:18 AM
There are not millions of dollars of invest here.


$8 million...

http://simhq.com/forum/ubbthreads.php/topics/3376003/Re_Commentary_IL_2_Sturmovik_R.html#Post3376003

Sokol1

Stublerone
12-20-2012, 06:57 AM
But 8 mio should be enough. Seems to be another problem like skill?.... Just saying.

SlipBall
12-20-2012, 07:27 AM
$8 million...

http://simhq.com/forum/ubbthreads.php/topics/3376003/Re_Commentary_IL_2_Sturmovik_R.html#Post3376003

Sokol1

I guess luthier was handed a real mess

carguy_
12-20-2012, 08:17 AM
I think you will find the whiners came before CoD, Tree made quite a stink for many a year before release and built himself a little cult following.....probably consisting of a large proportion of his own aliases.
if flawed software guaranteed failure then I don't think there would be any in existence, CoD was buggy, if I had a dollar for every buggy game I ever bought I'd have several hundred dollars, no the game didn't make money because enough people whined about it and it became undesireable, now we are going to wait a year for something inferior but works out of the box like a console game which I think is a backup plan.
Yes, and now you can see that the same people are trying to crash any memory of CloD. Even be it any good saying about any CloD feature that worked pretty well (uhm, ze cockpits?:rolleyes: ). Again , this is counterproductive and they already started this over at the new forum.
Declaring the title 'dead' or 'over' serves their agendas. The fact is that the further development of CloD is over, but the game can still be played online and offline. It just won`t expand anymore.

Blaf
12-20-2012, 08:46 AM
Yes, and now you can see that the same people are trying to crash any memory of CloD. Even be it any good saying about any CloD feature that worked pretty well (uhm, ze cockpits?:rolleyes: ). Again , this is counterproductive and they already started this over at the new forum.
Declaring the title 'dead' or 'over' serves their agendas. The fact is that the further development of CloD is over, but the game can still be played online and offline. It just won`t expand anymore.

The problem is, that actual version of CloD is very cut-down version of what this project would be capable of (comparison of basic Il-2 and Il-2 1946 4.12 comes to my mind)

Blaf
12-20-2012, 08:51 AM
Give it to oleg maddox, when he returns to the gaming manufacturing and let him set up a kickstarter project and let him present his ambitious visions, perhaps combining other aspects to a new ww2 sim and you will see the same as in star citizen from chris roberts.

+1
But its possible the trust of the community was harmed by initial CloD release so much that not many would support him. I would, though...

KG26_Alpha
12-21-2012, 11:51 AM
Can we please have the ALL the tools now???
since it is official i was wondering if we can have the tools to do with CloD what we can?I remember it was promised in the past and then we were told "no" because of possible future development,but since Clod is a stand alone and "abandoned" can we have what we need to make it "our" project?This community has been dedicated 100% and it would be pretty cool to have these tools available.
I know there are a few out there that would really like this and would do their best to make it nice.

There isn't any tools to release. Did you miss BlackSix' announcement on that?

looks like i did miss that one.thanks for the replies guys

~S~

Op's Q answered.