Ki-27 too durable & strange behavior

[CzechTexan]

Originally Posted by Pursuivant

I did extensive testing of the DM for all the planes in the game last winter.

http://forum.1cpublishing.eu/showthread.php?t=229446

ah, good to see the testing has been done!

IMO I still think the Ki-27 is tougher than it should be.
Quoting you: "For example, the Ki-43 series is far more durable than the A6M series."

It's true the Ki-43 is tougher and I'd have to say that so is the Ki-27. They should be flaming easier.
And, if a plane's wingtanks are on fire, they should not keep flying forever.

Thanks for the testing, Pursuivant. We can only hope the models get fixed for better realism.

[Pursuivant]

Originally Posted by CzechTexan

IMO I still think the Ki-27 is tougher than it should be.

Sadly, reworking DM so that they match the high quality of the FM in the game would require a huge amount of effort, almost a new game. It's a shame that IL2 was so careful with its flight models, but its damage models are so mediocre and so error-ridden.

I think that the Ki-27, A6M2, and Ki-43-I, being roughly contemporary planes, mostly built to higher pre-war quality standards, from the same materials, should all be equally vulnerable in the fuselage, stabilizers or wings. But that it should be much tougher to break wings, stabilizers, or fuselages on any plane due to damage alone (vs. damage from G forces + battle damage). Planes are big machines which are built to take extreme forces; putting a few small holes in them usually isn't going to make them fall apart.

The Ki-27, A6M2, and Ki-43-I are all desperately vulnerable to fuel tank hits, which is realistic, except for the fact that it should require a minimum of 2 bullets - one explosive or incendiary - to start any fuel fire. Also, since all three planes had wing fuel tanks right next to the wing spar, fuel fires or explosions should quickly cause wing failure, as well as injury to the pilot.

All three planes are also extremely vulnerable to crew hits, which is also realistic.

Fix the errors in the Ki-27's DM, and make all three planes approximately equal in ability to absorb engine, airframe, and control surface damage, and I'll be happy.

[Nil]

I confirm, the ki27 is bouncing, dancing on the tarmac!