Final Poll for CLOD?

[ChocsAway]

4 out of 10 as an offline player.

Lower than that though without the contributions of Heinkill and Desastersoft re content.

[tintifaxl]

Same here 4/10. Even with the Desastersoft campaigns. Too many bugs affecting offline and coop play. For me that's not enough to continue flying CloD.

[CWMV]

Originally Posted by tintifaxl

Same here 4/10. Even with the Desastersoft campaigns. Too many bugs affecting offline and coop play. For me that's not enough to continue flying CloD.

Agreed.
4/10 for me.

[Jugdriver]

7 out of 10 from me. Still having a blast online but there are just a few to many important omissions to make it rank higher IMO.

JD
AKA_MattE

[planespotter]

3. From me sorry but I cant help compare what was got with what they promised an I hoped for.

[icarus]

I gave it a 6 because the graphics are still unfinished and the SP play is so bad.

Not sure how anyone could vote 10 or 1 for that matter. Sarcasm votes I guess.

[foxl]

I gave it 5.

The lack of clouds ruins the game for me, they only appear close to you aircraft and they are the same as in old IL-2 just small puffs of cotton. Without clouds and some weather effect there is no flight sim experience.

[NedLynch]

5 for me.

single player here

-no dcg
-radio commands


That's it, I never really felt that all the fixes were so incredibly necessary.
Performance wise the game always ran just fine for me, I liked the graphics mostly, FM/DM were ok.
Yes a lot of things needed improving and improvements were made to great effect, I will not deny the devs my respect for their dedication.
But my biggest gripe has always been the lack of single player content, especially a dynamic campaign, so people can actually fly and have unrepetitive fun, despite all the other things that needed fixing.

[SharpeXB]

After experiencing DCS: P-51D I give the IL-2 flight and aircraft models a 4. They just feel game-like in comparison. The bar has been raised.
The GUI and commands/ menu system in CloD get a 2. It's like they were designed by someone who has never seen a flight sim. There are basic commands missing and absurdly illogical ones like the zoom feature that uses the mouse and button combo.
The game graphics get an 8 or 9 and the level of detail on the ground is astonishing. There's still a funny color palette and lack of weather. But the map is the best part of the sim. Also I give a 10 to how well it runs after the patch. For how well it looks it runs so smooth it's fantastic.
The mission design included with the game gets a 5. All air starts or ground starts with the engine running is so arcade.
Desastersoft I must try and it might be the whole redeeming feature.

[Ploughman]

6/10 for me. Playing off line there's very little content, it's a bit of a desert to be fair, on the other hand I recognise that CloD's got a lot of depth at its core and is quite enjoyable just as a aircraft study sim. Nice.