Red Tails Trailer #3

[winny]

Originally Posted by David Hayward

I never said that everyone who goes to a movie likes it, but it's certainly the best indication of how many people liked a movie. The Oscars are just the opinions of a well-connected group of people.

It's not an indication, it's an assumption.
You're the one who said money was the entire point. It is simply not true.
Nobody comes out of a film they've seen and liked and then changes their mind because it didn't do so well financially. The top grossing movies of all time contradict your point. Compare any online Best films of all time lists. That's a better indication. You may see films as a transaction, I see them as an art form.

I judge them on what I get from them, not how much they took from us.

You seem to like dropping grenades into conversations, you've said all Germans were Nazis, in a roundabout way. Completely disregarding the fact that to stand up against Hitler meant certain death, for you and most probably your family.
Are you personally responsible for all the bad things your government has done in your life time? It seems to me you'll say anything.

If you want to live in a world where everyone gets tarred with the same brush and the only value of art is financial then fine, but stop the world first coz I'm getting off.

[David Hayward]

Originally Posted by winny

It's not an indication, it's an assumption.
You're the one who said money was the entire point.

I hate to burst your bubble, but they make movies to make money. Lots of money. So they are going to make movies that they feel will advance that goal. Period.

[David Hayward]

Originally Posted by winny

you've said all Germans were Nazis, in a roundabout way.

I said nothing of the sort, in any way. I said that Germans followed a sociopath to war. Which they did.

[corchard]

Interesting explanation from George Lucas about his motivation and challenges of making "Red Tails".

George Lucas on the Daily Show

Charlo