More severe moderation in update threads?

[Igo kyu]

Originally Posted by Dutch_851

Personally, I find 'Great Update!', 'Fantastic!' 'Thanks Oleg!' or even 'First!' or 'Damn, Second!' just as tedious as the personal attacks between members that inevitably crop up.

If I did dream of stopping any posts, it would be all of the above without exception.

I actually voted the current moderation right, because I think it is, and I wouldn't want to see anything changed.

The elimination of the "this bit might be a bit wrong, perhaps?" posts to concentrate on the butt-kissing ones would entirely remove the point of the update threads for me.

[philip.ed]

Igo, I agree. Also, the majority of posts where users raise their concerns or post their own opinions are still very much applausing Oleg and co's work.
Normally it's along the lines of:
"excellent update, Oleg. I love the lighting in shot_ and the planes really do look photographic.
I was wondering___"

[Jaws2002]

Originally Posted by Igo kyu

If I did dream of stopping any posts, it would be all of the above without exception.

I actually voted the current moderation right, because I think it is, and I wouldn't want to see anything changed.

The elimination of the "this bit might be a bit wrong, perhaps?" posts to concentrate on the butt-kissing ones would entirely remove the point of the update threads for me.

Nobody is against that kind of imput. We are talking about this kind of imput:

"The clouds are *facepalm* "

"Computers have permanently developed better and better since the last 9 years. But SoW BoB doensn't look like 9 years better than IL-2. "

"Hm, I hope Oleg shows that he is grown-up and not in a snit now like a small child."

"Well Oleg:

The terrain still looks crappy and it's endless far from cinematic.

Some sort of trees in the pics look very poor..."

"Why does the water not show any effect to the crashing plane.
There should be circled waves going away from the entrance of the plane in the water.
And the trees in the second part of pictures just look very very bad."

"Even these clouds of 2006 version look better than the ones Oleg shows us in developments updates."

"The trees look like they would be flat green paper swimming on the water surface."

"It's very disappointing to be lured with video thoughts of luthier and then getting a few shots without anything new in it."

All this and a storm of stupid questions is coming from only one guy. And there are two maybe three others. Every friday is the same. This is crap, that is crap, i want this, i want that, you promised this.....

This is not constructive criticism. This are mostly insults. I'd be pissed to get this kind of stuff every week, for something I worked on for five years. Specially coming from some sixteen year old kid.

[Icewolf]

just keep adding the idiots to your ignore list ,easy solution.

[philip.ed]

Unless evidence is giving on members saying such things, surely your post is just as de-constructive and, thus, hypocritical? What's the saying: all talk, no action?
I mean I agree that such things are just rude, but I can't recall one member saying all that! I think it all get's spread across the board like marmite. That's metaphorical, and ambiguous, if you get my drift

I think we should put the past behind us and focus on the future. If the same thing happens, then-yes-we have reason to get annoyed.

[Jaws2002]

Originally Posted by philip.ed

Unless evidence is giving on members saying such things, surely your post is just as de-constructive and, thus, hypocritical?
What's the saying: all talk, no action?
I mean I agree that such things are just rude, but I can't recall one member saying all that! I think it all get's spread across the board like marmite.

Here's the evidence:

http://forum.1cpublishing.eu/search....archid=1428865

All the quotes posted above can be found there, in the exact same format. If you go read through that link you'll also see the constant "give me this, i want that", over and over again coming from the same guy.

[philip.ed]

Originally Posted by Jaws2002

Here's the evidence:

http://forum.1cpublishing.eu/search....archid=1428865

All the quotes posted above can be found there, in the exact same format.

The link doesn't work...

[Jaws2002]

Originally Posted by philip.ed

The link doesn't work...

For some reason only works when i'm logged with my user ID.

Ok anywhay, go to the last updates thread, go to the top of page#7, click on the user"Hecke" and then "find all posts bye Hecke"

You'll find everything there.


Let me try this link:

http://forum.1cpublishing.eu/search....nduser&u=19984


PS. I think this one works.

[McHilt]

Originally Posted by Igo kyu

If I did dream of stopping any posts, it would be all of the above without exception.

I actually voted the current moderation right, because I think it is, and I wouldn't want to see anything changed.

The elimination of the "this bit might be a bit wrong, perhaps?" posts to concentrate on the butt-kissing ones would entirely remove the point of the update threads for me.

Ok, the only input I always give here is my appreciation, which is considered just as tedious by some members. Maybe we have to shut up completely unless you're a highly intellectual insider with extremely valuable knowledge on the subject who has sth important and interesting to say, is that what you want to point out?. It would be an elitist place, reserved for the ones who are 'in the know' (whatever that means)... now, what is that???

[HFC_Dolphin]

It would be fantastic if we could all make only useful and to the point discussions!

There could always be "Off" topics if some people wanted to have some fun or discuss BS, but this discussion would not interfere with update threads where we look for usefull stuff.