Damage Model Bug Stomping

[RPS69]

Originally Posted by falconilia

If you fly historical air battles you dont have to worry about 0.50 caliber bullets but for lots of 20mms and some 13mm calliber (i think they are more powerfull but not tested).

So to minimize your results maybe you should test only vs Axis planes.
You will save time and strength!

I don't share your point of view.
Some Italian fighters have .50s as their only weapon. And they ARE vulnerable to .50s fire.

I also tested the effect of .50's on 190's, and even if they won't break their wings, it will become so unwieldy, that even an alive AI won't be capable of controlling it. That won't happen on a P51. Not with the same amount of fire.

[majorfailure]

Originally Posted by RPS69

I don't share your point of view.
Some Italian fighters have .50s as their only weapon. And they ARE vulnerable to .50s fire.

Italian .50 SAFAT is not anywhere near other HMGs, low RoF, low muzzle energy - still concentrated burst can make plane parts break, it is possible to shoot off a Hurricanes tail or wing, but usually you get unspectacular kills - fuel tank/pilot/controls/control surfaces/engine dead.

Originally Posted by Pursuivant

I'm guessing that the "damage threshold" classes are .30/.303 caliber & 7.62 mm, .50 caliber/12.7/13 mm, 20 mm & 30 mm. But, they might also be as simple as MG vs. cannon.

Please test UB HMG against planes you thought invulnerable against .50 cal. If I am not totally mistaken, you can break Fw190/F4U/F4F wings with it.

[Pursuivant]

Originally Posted by majorfailure

Please test UB HMG against planes you thought invulnerable against .50 cal. If I am not totally mistaken, you can break Fw190/F4U/F4F wings with it.

Is there a flyable plane in the game which has that weapon in a flexible gun mount?

[RPS69]

Originally Posted by Pursuivant

Is there a flyable plane in the game which has that weapon in a flexible gun mount?

IL2 3M, Pe2 and 3.

[Woke Up Dead]

Originally Posted by RPS69

IL2 3M, Pe2 and 3.

Except not the oldest series of the Pe2 in game.

[majorfailure]

Originally Posted by RPS69

IL2 3M, Pe2 and 3.

Also engine nacelle guns on Pe-8.

Does anyone know a useable platform for an Italian SAFAT 12.7mm or a German 13mm HMG?

[Torsteven]

Originally Posted by majorfailure

Also engine nacelle guns on Pe-8.

You can add the dorsal gun on IL-4.

Originally Posted by majorfailure

Also an Italian SAFAT 12.7mm

SM.79

Originally Posted by majorfailure

German 13mm HMG?

He-111 H-12

[Pursuivant]

Thanks to everyone for the suggestions for different gun types. I will definitely be checking some of these out.

My new project is to revisit my first experiment using the M2 .50 caliber HMG, but to try firing on target aircraft from angles other than just the front. This should give me a good picture of how all breaking parts work in the game.

Results so far indicate that most aircraft in the game are far more vulnerable to airframe damage than their size and construction would indicate. In particular, just about every aircraft in the game is very vulnerable to damage to wing & control surfaces. Even if you can't break a particular aircraft's wing, it's often incredibly easy to trigger damage textures on it

[falconilia]

Originally Posted by RPS69

I don't share your point of view.
Some Italian fighters have .50s as their only weapon. And they ARE vulnerable to .50s fire.

I also tested the effect of .50's on 190's, and even if they won't break their wings, it will become so unwieldy, that even an alive AI won't be capable of controlling it. That won't happen on a P51. Not with the same amount of fire.

AXIS side for me are German/Italian/Japan/Romanian planes.
Im sorry if i didnt mention it.

I flew some test missions P51D vs P51D.
I didnt brake any wing but also i didnt have to.
Few hits and was on fire or thick smoke on engine or with even fewer hits on wing AI couldnt control it.