Friday 2010-04-02 Video and Discussion Thread

[mark@1C]

Just some negative Pre-release feedback, I believe it is useful and necessary for BOSS to do his judgement, and a DEMO of WIP need negative more than positive(that's why every-friday thread exists). Let us leave the positive feedback to the released BoB/SoW.

[robtek]

I believe it works just the other way!!!
Now we can enjoy everything new and better.
At the release we can enjoy everything that has been kept secret.
Then, when we are enjoying the final Game, we can search for, maybe, needed improvements.

[Insuber]

Alright mate, but we have to say also what we like ... and a negative critique - or a positive one - must specify WHAT is missing or improvable ... otherwise it's too easy to say generically "you are far away" ... "60%" ... "my expectations are higher" ... but 60% OF WHAT ???

Originally Posted by mark@1C

Just some negative Pre-release feedback, I believe it is useful and necessary for BOSS to do his judgement, and a DEMO of WIP need negative more than positive (that's why every-friday thread exists). Let us leave the positive feedback to the released BoB/SoW.

[Freycinet]

I´ll say what noone else bothered to say. thanks for the vid johhny, very nice to see it in slowmo!

Also, I think it is really funny that so many people think that what we see in the updates are what they were "just working on this last week". Sorry guys, but what we are shown in the updates is often really old work on the sim... you can conclude NOTHING about the progress of the sim or the pace of progress from these updates...

[fireflyerz]

Originally Posted by mark@1C

Just some negative Pre-release feedback, I believe it is useful and necessary for BOSS to do his judgement, and a DEMO of WIP need negative more than positive(that's why every-friday thread exists). Let us leave the positive feedback to the released BoB/SoW.

+1
At last a person with a brain and not a brown nose.

[robtek]

Originally Posted by fireflyerz

+1
At last a person with a brain and not a brown nose.

I think that to wait for a finished product before looking for faults is mature.
You, as proved by this really "useful" comment, aren't.

[Flanker35M]

S!

Negative critics are needed to get progress. But it has to be well thought out, not just "OMG this suxxors" etc.

[fireflyerz]

Originally Posted by robtek

I think that to wait for a finished product before looking for faults is mature.
You, as proved by this really "useful" comment, aren't.

OMG , I hope you dont build the aircraft I fly in with that kind of forward thinking.

[KG26_Alpha]

Oleg Maddox

Hi,

Early in-game video. DX9 render and basic untuned effects. Do not forget – WIP!
Tracers are also WIP



In this thread the first post from Oleg, you should adjust comments to suit his statement regarding what you are seeing.







.

[Chivas]

Constructive criticism is a very good thing, but I see nothing in that video that requires negative feedback, that the developer isn't already well aware of. I'm not sure that negative reinforcement is a good thing, but that's just me.