Question for the Motor Heads

[Blakduk]

Bliss- unfortunately i live in an area where supercharged hotrods are rare so my opportunities to steal one are very limited. Also i'm a wuss and extremely scared of getting caught. Basically i have to take other people's word for how the real thing works.
Your argument makes sense, it seems plausible but.... i haven't seen the proof.

Basically i've got two engineers telling me different things, and two sims displaying different things (this could turn into another 'plane on a conveyor belt' thread)