[klem]

8 from me because........

For:
I play exclusively on line and it is very playable (within the limits of my rig).
I don't have to build the missions (thank you ATAG, 5./Jg27).
FMs 'feel' has moved forward since IL-2 '46.
I generallly like the environment we have been given (terrain, misting, etc).

Against:
A/C performances are still not right but at least the RAF planes can fight back now.
Map is still mickey mouse in these days of near-photographic accuracy and historical data on airfields etc.
The FMB could be a LOT friendlier for complex mission building. I would like to try it again but its an up-hill battle.

And I acknowledge the black hole in the ground that is offline play (so many people trying to play offline missions can't all be wrong) and the XP/DX9 debacle.

So I am voting from a very narrow selfish viewpoiint, otherwise it would have been a 5 because of all the other issues that don't affect me.