Hummm may I remind you that Il2 compare does not take into account E ?
The prob with the Spit in old Il2 was not so much with the numbers but with its relaxed "E-liability".
Somehow the very same happen here for now.
@Duk : your comment was funny to read. If I resum you said that It was hated as naturally too good... Sorry but didn't you forgot to mention the fact that only the very best flew the SPit in Il2