i had a Saitek x52
after that for 6 years a cougar
and now waiting for warthog
my favourite was the cougar
i dont know about the warthog cause i don't really test it so far
but i bet it would be SOMETHING
Also i had the chance to fly with a LOGITECH G940
with the rudders but i dont recommend that
you cannot find many latest drivers and the dead zones its a little triky