Gamespot Review for CoD - Score: 4.0

[Buchon]

Unplayable :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1LMft...layer_embedded

[David Hayward]

BTW repeatedly calling people morons isn't nearly as constructive as you seem to think it is.

[Positronic]

gamespot are usually quite slow on their PC reviews, so I'm a bit baffled they reviewed this before the NA release.

That said reviewers by policy have to review the game in released state, patches don't count. Gran turismo 5 suffered a similar fate.

oh well I have 56 hours into farming simulator 2011, and it scored a 2/10

[Hunden]

Originally Posted by Heliocon

Your proof for this is?



It just smacks of bad managment unfortunetly, but hopefully it will pull through and not stall.

Dude I don't know what your problem is but everything you have to say has a negative spin on it. Please if you dislike the game so much GO!!! somewhere else because your really becoming a Bore. I don't care if it dosen't look perfect this sim is going to succeed. So just stop.

[Heliocon]

Originally Posted by Hunden

Dude I don't know what your problem is but everything you have to say has a negative spin on it. Please if you dislike the game so much GO!!! somewhere else because your really becoming a Bore. I don't care if it dosen't look perfect this sim is going to succeed. So just stop.

Did I ever say it wont?
Did I ever say I hated it?

If I am becoming a bore then dont read my comments, simple. If you have low standards then buy the game and dont complain, because if everyone had the attitude you do, there would not of been the long term Il2 community and dev support that there is.

[Defender]

Can't say much to oppose that review, in all I think it was fair.

Although I'm a hard believer that WOP graphics won't have a profound impact on how great people find this game. A nice graphics package always comes at a price for content it seems.

I'm of the patient flight sim demographic, she's sitting on the HD until I can play it proper. DCS A-10C has come a long way in it's patches since release so I'm sure this will hopefully follow suit.

[Blakduk]

Cruel review but fair, especially from someone who obviously wants to boot the game up and play it without too much fuss.
I think the kind of buyer who relies on reviews like this would be advised to avoid this game in its current state- there are many broken elements as the reviewer described.
Personally, i'm really enjoying this game. It's a whole new challenge for me and i can overlook the current limitations and if the rate of improvement continues it will be brilliant in a few months.
The skills i learned in Il2 have to be relearned all over again and i get more a of sense in CoD that each plane is VERY individual. Current flightsim enthusiasts would be silly to give up on CoD because it has such great potential, but flightsim enthusiasts are very different to the average gamer.

[Hunden]

Originally Posted by Heliocon

Did I ever say it wont?
Did I ever say I hated it?

If I am becoming a bore then dont read my comments, simple. If you have low standards then buy the game and dont complain, because if everyone had the attitude you do, there would not of been the long term Il2 community and dev support that there is.

Let me get this straight, the Devs are going to support this sim because your complaining................and thats why there has been the long term il2 community............ you have got to be kidding me.

[Skissors]

oops same review

[baronWastelan]

Drink enough vodka, that 4 looks just like a 9. Say bye- bye to bad reviewski