hmm, before I read further, I think we need zero lift drag coefficient for 190 to say that weight is the deciding factor. wiki says 27.87 m² for p47 wing area and 18.30 m² for 190A. Agree with you that denominator (i.e., weight) is almost twice as large for p47 verses 190, but numerator? To keep simple math, assume zero drag coeff=1 for both planes, 190 weighs "1" and p47 weighs "2" (weight on relative basis to each other). Then drag coefficient portion of numerator
-dragcoefficentX(speed)^2/weight
where you did this -> P-47D-27 = 0.0256 * 25.87 = 0.662272 (i assume your using 25.87 for wing area)
(i.e., use 1 instead of .0256 and 1 for speed since same for both planes and 2 for weight p47 and 1 for weight of 190)
27.87/2 (p47) or 18.3/1 (190) is bigger??? The latter is bigger, and since it is a subtraction from this gXcos(60), wing area and/or differences in zero drag coeff may be the deciding factor in the calculation of dive acceleration, not the weight. And if this is the case, dive acceleration is less for 190 than p47. Sorry,if this is confusing. It's late here.
Last edited by MadBlaster; 05-12-2012 at 06:14 AM.
|