Quote:
Originally Posted by blackmme
Eh up, we have agreed to disagree but given the definition above.
Couple of things. 
The bombing of civilians in the Blitz was to achieve a completely different stated objective from the objective at the start of the Battle of Britain.
And given your definition above where do say Trafalgar and Midway fit?
there's no breaking of frontlines: Tick for both
loss or gain or territory: Tick for both
disbandment of an army: Tick for both
Or any other sign that would identify it as a battle.... Well other than one side very clearly achieved it's objectives and one side didn't
Your 'logic' doesn't work Stern, sorry.
Regards Mike |
I'm not an expert on Trafalgar, so I can't give you an assessment for that one, but Midway was indeed a gain of territory (it wasn't land per se, it was ocean control), and indeed the losses sustained by the Japanese were a critical hit from which they never fully recovered (unlike Germany in 1940).