I had the X52, only really used the throttle though, together with my MS FFB2 (best FFB stick so far imho).
I think the X52 is pretty good for its price. It's a little bit light-weight and does feel a bit like a toy (atleast the stick). The spring is very weak. The stick has a hall-effect sensor (= good precision + pretty much no wear & tear at all). Never had a problem with spikes on the throttle (which still uses potis, afaik).
Overall, even though i rarely used the stick, i would recommend it. I know quite a few people have it. Of course some people are experiencing problems with it (nothing is perfect).
Of course you would still need pedals. I tried the Saiteks once, the CH pedals are too narrow for me. I eventually bought Simpeds and am very happy with those. No problem whatsoever, perfect size, very precise and smooth action.
Well, because i mentioned the MS FFB2, i think it's one of the best flightsticks ever made and so far the best FFB stick, but it's not really an option if you also need to buy pedals and a throttle.
I only heard good things about the CH sticks and throttle. Of course they're not cheap, but they seem to be worth it.
I'm using a HOTAS Warthog for two months now. I think it's great, very expensive but (so far) worth the price. Excellent feeling and precision, the throttle is the best i ever tried/owned. Perfect smooth action, many switches and a pretty good software (atleast i don't have any problems with it). The stick is a bit stiff. I'll probably try to weaken the spring somehow, to improve precision.
|