Official Fulqrum Publishing forum - CloDo review of a french video game mag...

Official Fulqrum Publishing forum (http://forum.fulqrumpublishing.com/index.php)

- IL-2 Sturmovik: Cliffs of Dover (http://forum.fulqrumpublishing.com/forumdisplay.php?f=189)

- - CloDo review of a french video game mag... (http://forum.fulqrumpublishing.com/showthread.php?t=21678)

Quote:

Originally Posted by 159th_Jester (Post 267101)

Well as a review, that is an awful piece of writing. Not much better than the average complaining thread you'll find on any game forum.

The writer gives no facts to back up his opinion. He gives no real technical information. In fact he gives nothing. All he's sone is state an unsupported opinion.

However when considering the original release, his score is right. He can't review what might be, he can only review what's in front of him. Considering this in the light of the 4/10 from Gamestop means the writing is very much on the wall. I can't help but wonder how long it will be until Ubi start to think they're on a loser here and force 1C to drop the project in a similar way they dropped SH5 very quickly when that emerged to less than stellar reviews.

However right or not, he should be fired for being so unproffessional to right such a badly considered "review." .... And his editor should be fired for being so incompetant as to publish it.

I guess you don't know the mag' and I can't blame you for that but... what you're complaining about is exactly what this mag' is about : not any so-called "professional objectivity bullshit and so on". They really give their opinion about the game they're testing, no matter if that seems strange, weird, crappy, or, especially, unprofessional...

And they have no editor, they're independent, they own their own mag'.

I know this mag' well. It's the best PC video games Mag' you can buy here in France. Period.

You should read my message too I've posted at the bottom of the first page too BTW. :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by ICDP (Post 266933)

I understand all of the abover are not bugs, but that doesn't mean CoD has only a few bugs. FMs, DMs, performance, UI bugs, Campaign bugs, sound bugs, controller bugs, loadout bugs, FMB bugs, stability bugs, broken radio commands etc.

Face it, CoD is seriously bugged and deserves the low scores it is getting. I personally would give it 50% and that would be generous.

U forgot BUGS bugs.

Dont wanna go into why u have decided the pretty much everything have bugs in one form or another. I guess u know every detail of the game after only 2 weeks, quick learner maby.

Just because U think its a bug, doesnt mean it IS a bug.

P.S. If u find u have stability "bugs" for ex. my suggestions is: uncheck all the boxes in the difficulty section, that should do the trick (or turn of Twitter, Messenger and Spottify when u play). That might even fix the FM and DM "bugs" to.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Baron (Post 267171)

Thankfully the proper reviews are tearing this so called "sim" to shreds. Just because you think it isn't a bug doesn't mean the reviews that matter won't.

Oh and well done on your reading comprehension... tool.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ICDP (Post 267185)

Im not talking about the reviewer, im talking about U announcing that everything has bugs ,witch is bollocks.

But i think u allredy know that, u just need to lash out because U cant get it to work like many can.

This is not a review per se, it's just a small sum up, the full review being published in the paper magazine. Should be at least 2 pages per their standards.

The reviewer has produced in depth reviews of many titles (including DCS A-10, Blackshark and so on), and i found him usually quite generous with sims. I am pretty sure that if/when the game gets really seriously working well with all features (comms, dynamic weather), one can ask for an up to date review and get it. Still, the game was what it was at release, review was most probably written before the two last patches (then it could have been rated 5/10 maybe, with what is still broken/not working as advertised).

3/10 would have been my rating too at release, 1/10 for game as released and 2/10 for hope of improvement. I'd give it a 5,5 now, improvements have been much faster than expected. Hope to give it a 9 six months from now :rolleyes:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Baron (Post 267209)

I have it working well on my PC thanks for your concern. Like it or not sunshine, this game has more bugs than a termite mound. you keep saying "IT ISN'T A BUG...WAH", who are you trying to convince, the rest uf us who have the sim and know it is bugged, or yourself?

Either way, I have decided to stop debating with you on this. Enjoy your bug free sim.