PDA

View Full Version : Fighters in focus - SPEED


DKoor
10-04-2007, 12:01 PM
http://i119.photobucket.com/albums/o125/DKoor/smileys/deadhorse.gif
Measured in v4.08 on Crimea map.
Results are very accurate, tolerance for error is less than 1%.......... I'll update the list and add new info as I do new tests.

http://i23.tinypic.com/5akiaa.gif

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

And here are differences in speed.................IL-2 V4.08 vs IL-2 Compare V4.07.
Differences are expressed in %.......so those having a positive % have actually greater speed than expected, and those that have -% have less speed than expected.
All values are measured at SL, except those marked with *, which are obtained at max speed altitude (see some test above for more info).

http://i21.tinypic.com/1z5lpq9.gif

________
update#2

bigbossmalone
10-04-2007, 02:44 PM
Very nice, DKoor!
Good to see some 'sensible' stuff appearing here!
I'm going to spend the next few days testing your listed speeds for accuracy, if y'all don't mind.
Purely because I don't have that much else to do right now...
Oh, I assume you were using full ECM settings for these tests?
Cheers
:D

BTW, I knew there was a reason why I liked the P40 so much, and it looks pretty impressive in blue on the list!

DKoor
10-04-2007, 08:12 PM
Thanks.

All fighters were tested at full CEM settings with all stuff....
I only enabled pit off and speedbar :)

BTW top speeds at level are reached at around ~2mins after flying at top speed and with almost absolutely no deviation in course and height.

I used QMB.

ImMoreBetter
10-04-2007, 09:02 PM
:P Hope you don't mind...


A6M2-21 ----------- 436
A6M2 --------------- 437
A6M3 --------------- 471
A6M7-63 ----------- 471
Bf-109E4 ----------- 486
Bf-109E7Z --------- 486
Bf-109G6AS ------- 591
Bf-109G10 --------- 580
Bf-109G14 --------- 576
Bf-109K4 ----------- 587
F4F-4 --------------- 466
F4U-1D ------------- 576
F6F-5 --------------- 521
FW-190A5-165 ---- 589
FW-190A5 --------- 576
FW-190A6 --------- 576
FW-190A9 --------- 596
FW-190D9E ------- 616
IAR.81a ------------ 483
J8A ----------------- 337
Ki-43II ------------- 457
Ki-43II-KAI -------- 457
LA-5 ---------------- 558
LA-5FN ------------- 572 (with droptanks)
LA-5FN ------------- 590 (default)
LA-5FN ------------- 590 (after released droptanks)
LA-5FN ------------- 641 (at 6,000m)
LaGG-3S29 -------- 520
LaGG-3S35 -------- 526
LaGG-3S66 -------- 551
MC.202III --------- 509
MC.202-XII ------- 508
MC.205-III -------- 542
N1K2 --------------- 564
N1K2 --------------- 599 (at 5,000m)
P-40M -------------- 484
P-40M -------------- 583 (at 6,100m)
P-47D27 ----------- 547 (with 2x500lb on)
P-47D27 ----------- 577 (after released 2x500lb)
P-47D27 ----------- 578 (default armament)
P-51D -------------- 608
P-51D -------------- 677 (at 3,000m)
P-51D -------------- 723 (at 7,500m)
Spitfire Vb --------- 468
Spitfire Vc2xH ---- 468
Spitfire Vc4xH ---- 468
Spitfire IXe -------- 538
TA-152C ----------- 612
TA-152H ----------- 603

DKoor
10-04-2007, 09:13 PM
GREAT! 8)

I just wanted to do that, but somehow with all those options (quote, code, list etc.) I got owned.

:(

Simple way is always the best 8)

Thanks IMB!

Megile
10-04-2007, 09:24 PM
P-47Dora only looses 1kph with 2 * 500?

How queer :?:

DKoor
10-04-2007, 10:30 PM
P-47Dora only looses 1kph with 2 * 500?

How queer :?:ERROR ERROR ERROR

Me sorry.........forgot to mention that I released those bombs :P
So drag caused by center rack (dunno why it is mounted there in the first place, as it is not necessary for 2x500lb loadout) costs ya 1km/h. Anyhow I don't wanna get into the discussion about un-logical racks and drags here just pure info....................FW-190A is heavily affected by unnecessary racks (when you select only inboard cannons your speed is actually lower :!: :!: :!: because game adds a nice rack to your FW-190 :?: :? :? ).........sorry couldn't resist :P

So correct P-47D27 speeds are;

P-47D27 547 (with 2x500lb on)
P-47D27 577 (after released 2x500lb)
P-47D27 578 (default armament)

Thanks Megile 8)

mottom
10-06-2007, 11:05 AM
I did a similar list for sea level speeds some time ago. Some results are from 4.07m, others from 4.08m. What I have seen the results from DKoor and mine are withing 1%.

mottom


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Krimea, 12:00, over Sea, direction 180deg; max Power (110% + WEP if avail); Radiator closed; 100% fuel, wounder woman view; full real (incl overheat and turbulence)

Type------------------v[km/h] 0m----Comment

A6M2-21----------------435
B-239-------------------427
BF109 E4---------------486
BF109 E4B-------------453 SC250
BF109 E4B-------------473
BF109 F2---------------519
BF109 F4---------------528
BF109 G10-------------579
BF109 G14-------------575
BF109 G2---------------545
BF109 G2---------------540 Radiator 2
BF109 G2---------------535 Radiator 4
BF109 G2---------------533 Radiator 6
BF109 G2---------------529 Radiator 8
BF109 G2---------------526 Radiator Open
BF109 G2---------------526 Radiator Auto
BF109 G2---------------528
BF109 G6 Late---------534
BF109 G6AS------------591
BF109 K4---------------585
BF109 K4 C3-----------595
BF110 G2---------------515
Buffalo MKI-------------427
DO323 A0--------------620
FW190 A4--------------546
FW190 A4--------------542 Radiator 2
FW190 A4--------------536 Radiator 4
FW190 A4--------------530 Radiator 6
FW190 A4--------------528 Radiator 8
FW190 A4--------------524 Radiator Open
FW190 A4--------------524 100% Power
FW190 A4--------------558 CSP
FW190 A5--------------532 700kg Bombs droped
FW190 A5 1.6----------544 700kg Bombs droped
FW190 A5 1.6----------588
FW190 A6--------------574
FW190 A8--------------584
FW190 A9--------------594
FW190 D9--------------613
FW190 D9 Late--------620
FW190 F8--------------571
Hawk81A2-------------468
Hurrican MKIIb--------418
I153M-62--------------358
I153P------------------358
I16 Type 18-----------417
I16 Type 24-----------443
I185 M71--------------610
IL2 3-er----------------423 400 kg Bombs + 8xBRS-82
IL2 3-er----------------439
JU88 A4----------------380 4000 kg Bombs
JU88 A4----------------391
KI43A------------------435
La5---------------------525 no WEP
LA5F--------------------555
LA5FN------------------590
LA7---------------------610
LaGG3 29--------------463 8xRS-82
LaGG3 29--------------518 8xRS-82 fired
LaGG3 29--------------518
LaGG3 35--------------525
LaGG3 4---------------487 100% Power
LaGG3 4---------------503
LaGG3 66--------------548
MÉ 262-----------------855
Mosquito MKVI--------530 4x500lb Bombs
Mosquito MKVI--------558
Mustang MKIII--------650
P38J--------------------527 12x4.5'' Rockets
P38J--------------------572
P38L Late--------------592
P39D1-----------------504
P40C-------------------467
P40E-------------------480
P40E M105 Fieldmod--480
P40M-------------------482
P47ED------------------582
P51D 20NA------------602
Spitfire MKVb----------467
Spitfire LF MKVb-------525
Spitfire MK IXc---------540
Spitfire MK IX 25 lbs---572
TA152C-----------------610
TA152H1----------------602
Tempest MKV-----------607
Tomahawk MKIIa-------468
YAK1---------------------480
YAK1b-------------------537
YAK3---------------------573
YP80---------------------845

DKoor
10-06-2007, 12:22 PM
8) Great! Thanks for the list man :D

fly_zo
10-06-2007, 12:50 PM
so in conclusion:the list it's accurate as it can be !
Thanks for all effort guys, it will sure help me when choosing my flight

saving it for reference

thanks again :D

Z

ImMoreBetter
10-06-2007, 03:14 PM
Great! So what are ya'll going to work on next? :)

DKoor
10-07-2007, 05:45 PM
I did the P-38s, deck and on best speed alt, with default and heaviest l0ad (10xHVAR + 2x1,000lb).

I'll do some more stuff..... 8)
At deck and best speed alt.

American fighters this time 8)

It would be interesting to see some bomber speeds....... 8)

fly_zo
10-07-2007, 06:31 PM
I did the P-38s, deck and on best speed alt, with default and heaviest l0ad (10xHVAR + 2x1,000lb).

I'll do some more stuff..... 8)
At deck and best speed alt.

American fighters this time 8)

It would be interesting to see some bomber speeds....... 8)

could you please do Seafires ?

thanks

DKoor
10-07-2007, 08:44 PM
Rgr I'll do it.............probably post results here tomorrow :)

fly_zo
10-07-2007, 08:59 PM
thanks :D

DKoor
10-08-2007, 07:30 PM
could you please do Seafires ?

thanks

Seafire FIII 413 with rockets, SL
Seafire FIII 431 rockets fired, SL
Seafire FIII 443 with 500lb, SL
Seafire FIII 460 released 500lb, SL
Seafire FIII 471 SL
Seafire FIII 581 5300m
Seafire LIII 515 SL
Seafire LIII 541 1900m

_________________
red - max level speed

fly_zo
10-08-2007, 07:34 PM
thanks so very much m8 :D

DKoor
10-08-2007, 10:19 PM
OK I did a little update.......there are some uncommon (relatively) results like those of Mosquito......dam that fighter-bomber is fast!
For instance, it's absolute top speed is faster 7km/h than those of N1K2-Ja! :shock:
Take into account that we are comparing 1942 wooden fighter-bomber to the late war 1945 fighter!

Kira1985
10-09-2007, 12:01 AM
I couldn't out run a 25lbs Spit - for too long :twisted: -, and couldn't out turn it in the Mosquito. So I say it's undermodeled. :P

DKoor
10-09-2007, 12:39 AM
Depends what you flew in against them........................
Imagine if we get 1944 Mosquito 8) he he fast mf...... :P
Spitfire is not that fast aircraft someone could expect it to be.
Virtual Luftwaffe in their 109s and wurgers should be able to run away from them.

:evil:

na85
10-09-2007, 07:33 PM
To bring this forum on right course, here is one 100% on topic thread.
I saw some of you folks complaining how everything about IL-2 is a dead horse (http://i119.photobucket.com/albums/o125/DKoor/smileys/deadhorse.gif) well it ain't 8) ! There are many interesting things to be played with.
Measured in v4.08 on Crimea map.
Results are very accurate, tolerance for error is less than 1%.......... I'll update the list and add new info as I do new tests.
Special remarks listed;

....

Results marked in red are obtained by flying at the t0p speed alts, that means those are absolute t0p level speeds for the specific type.
________
update#1

Are those speed values in IAS or TAS?

DKoor
10-09-2007, 07:40 PM
Those are values that can be read on the "Comic Gauge", another words, TAS 8)

MrMojok
10-09-2007, 09:24 PM
Nice :)

Kurfürst
10-15-2007, 08:39 PM
I did a similar list for sea level speeds some time ago. Some results are from 4.07m, others from 4.08m. What I have seen the results from DKoor and mine are withing 1%.

BF109 G2---------------545
BF109 G2---------------540 Radiator 2
BF109 G2---------------535 Radiator 4
BF109 G2---------------533 Radiator 6
BF109 G2---------------529 Radiator 8
BF109 G2---------------526 Radiator Open
BF109 G2---------------526 Radiator Auto
BF109 G2---------------528


Interesting stuff on the radiator`s drag effect. For comparison with RL tested data for radiator drag on a Bf 109G-1, please see my site :

http://kurfurst.allaboutwarfare.com/Performance_tests/109G1_messung601e605a/files/blatt9.jpg

It seems the radiator has very little effect on drag state compared to real life..

DKoor
10-19-2007, 09:48 PM
I've compared another set of data..........
To some this may be actually worthwhile......
See how much actual difference is between the Gospel IL-2 Compare V4.07 and IL-2 V4.08.

Some may be surprised.

msalama
10-20-2007, 06:48 AM
Excellent work Mr. DeKoor. A big ~S~ for your efforts.

I've always wondered what my favorite ride the Pe-2 would do at altitude... any chance of you checking her when you have the time? You do that and I'll buy you a beer sometime! 8)

DKoor
10-20-2007, 07:53 AM
Excellent work Mr. DeKoor. A big ~S~ for your efforts.

I've always wondered what my favorite ride the Pe-2 would do at altitude... any chance of you checking her when you have the time? You do that and I'll buy you a beer sometime! 8)Not a prob...............she and teh IL-2s are already scheduled.

crazyivan1970
10-20-2007, 05:43 PM
I think you outdone tagert on this one D.

:D

msalama
10-20-2007, 07:59 PM
S! m8 & thx.

DKoor
10-21-2007, 12:39 AM
I think you outdone tagert on this one D.

:D :twisted:


msalama:

Pe-2s1.......SL.......466 default
Pe-2s1.......4700...548 default
Pe-2s84.....SL.......447 default
Pe-2s84.....4600...525 default
Pe-2s110....SL.......440 default
Pe-2s110....4600...516 default
Pe-2s359....SL.......485 default
Pe-2s359....3900...534 default
Pe-2s359....SL.......448 2x500kg+2x250kg
Pe-2s359....SL.......483 6x100kg (internal!)
Pe-2s359....SL.......485 after releasing 2x500kg+2x250kg

msalama
10-21-2007, 05:24 PM
Thank you Sir, I owe you one. Will copy this to my files in order to do some comparisons w/ whatever RL data I'm able to find later on...

S! and thanks again m8 8)

RockStar
10-23-2007, 05:42 PM
Great list sir, thanks for sharing.

SG1_Gunkan
10-23-2007, 06:22 PM
Great information. I fly FW190 and the speed is my virtual life! Thanks a lot.

Vike
10-23-2007, 07:38 PM
Interesting thread DKoor :)

:arrow: Maximum performance obtained on
Crimea Map,noon,sea level,closed rads & ball centered.
Full switch settings.

Me109 K4 1.98ATA C3 1945:
TAS max=598Km/h

Me109 G6/AS 1944:
TAS max=592Km/h

Me109 K4 1.80ATA B4 1944:
TAS max=588Km/h

Me109 G10 1944:
TAS max=581Km/h

Me109 G14 1944:
TAS max=577Km/h

Me109 G2 1942:
TAS max=545Km/h

Me109 G6 "Late" 1943:
TAS max=537Km/h

Me109 G6 "early" 1943:
TAS max=530Km/h

Me109 F4 1941:
TAS max=528Km/h

Me109 F2 1941:
TAS max=520Km/h

Me109 E4 1939:
TAS max=487Km/h

=======================

Same settings with Twin-engined german planes:

Dornier Do335-A0 1944:
TAS max=625km/h

Me110 G2 conf. standard (4 MG17 + 2 MG151/20) 1942:
TAS max=525km/h

Me110 G2-R3 (2 MK108 + 2 MG151/20) 1942:
TAS max=523km/h

Me110 G2-R3M1 (2 MK108 + 4 MG151/20) 1942:
TAS max=514km/h


=======================

Same settings with Jets:

Me262 HG-II
TAS max=950km/h (WOOT!)

Ta183
TAS max=909km/h

Ho/Go229
TAS max=835km/h

Me262 A-1a 1944:
TAS max=834km/h

==========================


:arrow: Load-out influence on Me109 G6/AS.
Crimea Map,noon,sea level,closed rads & ball centered.
Full switch settings

Clean Config:
See above.

With Rack ETC250:
4xSC50:TAS max=544km/h
2xSC50 (2 on 4 dropped):TAS max=553km/h
Rack ETC250 alone:TAS max=575km/h

With Rack ETC500:
1xSC250:TAS max=551km/h
Bomb dropped,rack ETC500 alone:TAS max=575km/h

1xSC500:TAS max=548km/h
Bomb dropped,rack ETC500 alone:TAS max=575km/h

1xDropTank 300 liters type D :TAS max=565km/h
Tank dropped,rack ETC500 alone:TAS max=575km/h

With Gunpods:
2xGUN-PODS 20mm:TAS max 558km/h
2xGUN-PODS 30mm:TAS max 558km/h

@+

DKoor
10-23-2007, 08:40 PM
Here's one tip guys....................................

If you carry bombs, and you have option to carry internal load - do it.

See Pe-2 tests on page two for further info.

That is valid as some kind of a general rule with all ac.